*To save this chart as your own so you can type on it, go to MAKE A COPY (under File Menu) and save it to your google drive.
AUTHOR/ CONCEPT
|
Overall claims and arguments
|
Key words
|
Connection to another author?
|
Story from my SL project
|
SCWAAMP
|
Leslie Grinner argues that there are some categories/identities that are most valued (dominant) in our culture and they are privileged, or given more access and opportunity than other categories/identities that are not valued. These Most Valued categories are invisible to us unless we “tap the glass” to notice they are there. What kinds of things are valued at your SL site? Any evidence of taps on the glass of dominant ideology?
|
dominant ideology
privilege
tap the glass
|
Johnson talks about same concepts, Delpit’s culture of power
|
Some students may have issues
having an internship because of
their race.
|
Allan Johnson argues that it is important to talk explicitly about issues of privilege, power and difference so that we can work towards a more just and respectful world. Do you see any examples of teachers or students talking explicitly about race, class, gender, sexuality, etc? What kind of outcomes do you witness? Is it productive or confrontational? Would Johnson celebrate these efforts?
|
“Say the words”
“Luxury of obliviousness”
|
Delpit (“good intentions are not enough”)
|
There are group talks about
gender , race, and social class and sexuality.
| |
Delpit
|
Lisa Delpit argues that teachers need to explicitly teach the rules and codes of power to students who might not learn those rules and codes at home. Have you seen teachers using a direct style? Have you seen teachers working to instruct students about the rules and codes of power? Have you come across “Delpit Moments” where there was a miscommunication that could be related to these issues?
|
Codes of power
|
Christensen
Codes of power / take power
|
All students respect the rules and codes.
|
(Ted Nugent) “ That the takers in society are entitlement chumps and gluttonous, souls pigs.”
|
Opportunity
In balance
|
Christensen
opportunity
|
Real life opportunity
Internships
| |
Kozol
|
“Because they are classified as only poor not destitute
|
Individuals
Vs Institutions
|
Kristof
Class of a person
|
All come from different backgrounds and different classes of people
|
McIntosh
|
McIntosh suggests that white people are taught not to recognize the way their race gets valued in the larger culture. She says that unless white people actively pay attention to it, whiteness will go unnoticed and unacknowledged. Have you seen whiteness valued at your schools? Does whiteness show its power in the leadership, curriculum, norms or expectations of the classroom?
|
Whiteness
Norms
Leadership
Power
|
Johnson
Power privilege
|
Every person has a place of power
No race or sexuallity is favorited
|
“All Lives Matter”
|
All people vs. just black people
|
All lives vs.just black lives
|
Johnson
race
|
Some are pro black lives matter some are for all lives matter
|
Rodriguez
|
Talks about the separation between his “home” language and culture and the language/culture of academia. He feels he had to leave behind his home language to become fluent and successful in another.
|
Struggle to fit in trying to understand different lang.
|
Concern
Struggle
Johnson / McIntosh
|
Many people speak two or more lang. Some just one
|
Garcia
|
Discusses the benefits of translanguaging, where students can use all available linguistic resources to discuss, learn, and understand concepts.
|
Lang. practices of bilingual people
|
Positive
Helpful
Johnson
|
Helping others learn
Team work
|
Christensen
|
Christensen argues that schools need to help students acquire tools to interpret the media and other cultural texts in order to recognize stereotypes and oppression. Further, she emphasizes that teachers need to help students take action in expression their critiques. Do you see any of this connection to the “real world” in your SL classroom? Do students learn to take action and speak out?
|
Stereotypes
Oppression
|
Johnson
Delpit
Very opinionated
|
Voiced their opinions
Openly and have group talks everyday
|
August
|
August argues that people can’t learn if they don’t feel safe. Schools need to work to make marginalized students (in her case students who identify as LGBT) feel more “normalized” into the school community. She suggest we can do this by fighting the tendency to make these students erased, absent and invisible. Do you see these kind of efforts (around gayness or other issues) present in your school?
|
LGBT erased
Normalized
|
Rodriguez
LGBT supported
Johnson
Sexuality
|
Students and teachers both talk about ways to help LGBT community and students
|
Zelle
| one who is one gender but likes or wants to be another | LGBT | Christensen,Johnston, McIntosh | LGBT is largely supported |
Kahne and Westheimer
|
Charity vs. Change
“Ask not what your country can do for you: ask what you can do for your country”
|
Real world learning
|
Christensen
Real world skill |
Internships
Community service
|
This American Life
|
Segregation of students or desegregation of students
|
Suffering
depression
|
Johnson / SWAAMP
|
Everyone goes to one school together all races no segregation
|
Hebert
|
separate educational facilities are inherently unequal
|
Separate
Unequal
|
Brown v. Board of
Education
|
Everyone is seen as equal but not by all internship mentors in the community
|
Brown v Board website
|
(1954) case to end segregation which affected changes in nation and social policy
|
Courage
Change
Peoples rights
|
Peoples rights
Hebert
|
Teachers educate on this topic and view in as important to understand
|
Finn
| middle class schools and high performing schools | rich vs poor vs middle class | Johnson because of social class and power | everyone has there own way of teaching some soft spoken some are more demanding |
Oakes
| one persons needs compared to another | deprived and some are not some gain more knowledge than others | Finn class and knowledge | every student gets one on one meetings with there teachers no student left behind |
Kliewer
| students with special needs can feel left out, because they may be smarter than people take them to be, and should be given the chance to take other classes to improve there education. "Now we know that people with disabilities can learn and have a full, rich life. The challenge is to erase negative attitudes about people with develop- mental disabilities, get rid of the stereotypes and break the barriers for people with disabilities." | education deprived working toward better education | shor | This is not what happens at my school they get equal learning and treatment. |
Shor
| Give students the education they deserve, not just what you think they can do or what you think they deserve. | education deprived | Kilewer | No one judges students way of learning. |
Privilege
| able to be above everyone else, to rise above, to be higher in rank, or seen as a better person because of race, class, sex, or family | lower class looked down on as upper class gets everything jobs depending on race or sex - unfair | Johnson, August, Delpit, McIntosh | the only time I have seen this happen is when students are trying to get internships and not treated fairly by the community |
Power
| whites have power over minority | Whites- seen as a higher power minority- seen as lower power which is all other races | Johnson, Delpit | treated as equals in power in school but in the community they are not |
Ideology
| policy and ideas for and economic system | the system does little to help the schools in need | Brown v. board of education | this school does not seem to have very many problems that I know of |
individuals vs institutions
| individual is dealing with oppression and inequality institutions are dealing with oppression as well but to feel forgotten or to feel control within a group which individual is cruel treatment and tossed aside or controls power | inequality and oppression | Johnson, Delpit, Kristof | to change fate and prove that everyone has power in one way or another |
social justice
| affects schools and way of life | teaching, learning, jobs, life | I would say all the authors because this subject involves something in many of the subjects talked about by everyone | Students bring this subject up in class and teachers would assign projects to help students better understand social justice |
No comments:
Post a Comment